Constitutional law / Judicial appointments

No Reservation in High Court Judge Appointments: Madhya Pradesh High Court

The Madhya Pradesh High Court held that the Constitution of India does not prescribe reservation or proportionate representation of SC, ST, OBC or EWS categories in the appointment of High Court judges. It also reiterated that appointment to a constitutional judicial office is different from recruitment to an executive civil post.

Case at a glance

Case
Maruti Sondhiya v. Union of India & Others
Court
High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Jabalpur
Case number
Writ Petition No. 28550 of 2023
Decision
28 May 2024
Bench
Acting Chief Justice Sheel Nagu and Justice Amar Nath (Kesharwani)
Result
Writ petition dismissed at the admission stage

Background of the petition

The petitioner, an advocate, challenged the Union Government notification dated 2 November 2023 appointing seven judges to the Madhya Pradesh High Court under Article 217(1). He contended that although he had completed the requisite ten years of legal practice, he had not been considered for appointment. He also objected to the absence of a public advertisement, written examination or interview, and alleged inadequate representation of Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, Other Backward Classes and Economically Weaker Sections.

Constitutional provisions governing judicial appointments

Article 217(1): Appointment of High Court judges

Article 217(1) provides for appointment of High Court judges by the President of India following the constitutionally required consultations. A permanent High Court judge ordinarily holds office until the age of 62 years, subject to constitutional provisions regarding resignation, removal, transfer and appointment to the Supreme Court.

Article 217(2): Eligibility to become a High Court judge

Under Article 217(2), a person must be an Indian citizen and must have either held judicial office in India for at least ten years or been an advocate of a High Court, or of two or more High Courts in succession, for at least ten years. These are eligibility conditions, not a guarantee of selection or an enforceable right to be considered merely because the conditions are met.

Article 141: Binding force of Supreme Court law

Article 141 states that the law declared by the Supreme Court is binding on all courts within India. The judicial precedents interpreting the constitutional appointment process therefore govern the functioning of the collegium system.

Article 226: High Court writ jurisdiction

Article 226 empowers High Courts to issue appropriate writs and directions for enforcement of fundamental rights and for other purposes. The petitioner invoked this jurisdiction to challenge the appointment notification.

What the Madhya Pradesh High Court decided

1. Ten years of practice does not confer an entitlement to appointment

The Bench explained that meeting the minimum eligibility requirement under Article 217(2)(b) does not mean that every eligible advocate must be considered or appointed by the High Court and Supreme Court collegiums.

2. Judicial appointments are not ordinary civil-service recruitment

The Court distinguished the constitutional office of a High Court judge from an executive civil post. It held that the appointment procedure flows from the Constitution as interpreted by binding Supreme Court decisions, and cannot be replaced by ordinary recruitment procedures. The absence of a public advertisement, written examination or viva voce did not invalidate the appointments.

3. No constitutionally mandated reservation quota in High Court judge appointments

Rejecting the petitioner's representation-based challenge, the Bench found that neither the constitutional provisions governing appointments nor the binding judicial precedents prescribe reservation or adequate or proportionate representation of SC, ST, OBC or EWS categories in the appointment of High Court judges. The Court therefore declined to invalidate the appointments on that ground.

This holding concerns appointments to the constitutional office of High Court judge. It should not be confused with reservation rules applicable to public employment or recruitment to judicial services, which operate under different constitutional and statutory frameworks.

4. Collegium decisions derive authority from constitutional case law

The Court referred to the evolution of the collegium system through Supreme Court judgments, including S.P. Gupta v. Union of India (1981), Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of India (1993), the Special Reference No. 1 of 1998, and the 2015 NJAC judgment reported in (2016) 5 SCC 1. The collegium system is not expressly named in the constitutional text but operates under the Constitution as interpreted by the Supreme Court.

Outcome and legal significance

The High Court dismissed the writ petition in limine, finding no legal basis to grant the requested relief. The decision clarifies the distinction between constitutional qualifications and entitlement to appointment, and between judicial appointments and competitive public-service recruitment.

Although the judgment rejects a claim for legally mandated reservation or proportional representation in High Court appointments, it does not establish that diversity cannot be considered as a policy objective. The specific ruling is that the petitioner's proposed quota-based challenge did not arise from an enforceable constitutional requirement in this appointment process.

Authorities and further reading

Frequently asked questions

Is reservation mandatory in appointments of High Court judges?

No reservation quota is prescribed for appointments of High Court judges under Article 217. The Madhya Pradesh High Court reaffirmed this position in its decision of 28 May 2024.

Can every advocate with ten years of practice demand consideration for judgeship?

No. Ten years of qualifying advocacy is a constitutional eligibility condition, not an automatic right to be considered or appointed.

Is an advertisement or written examination required for High Court judge appointments?

No. The constitutional appointment procedure, as interpreted by the Supreme Court, does not require the standard advertisement-and-examination process used in many public-service recruitments.

Legal note: This article reports and explains a 2024 judgment and the relevant constitutional framework. It is general legal information, not advice on an individual appointment dispute.