Banking Law / Cyber Fraud / Bombay High Court
Bombay High Court Orders Bank of Baroda to Refund Rs 76.90 Lakh in Cyber Fraud Case
In Jaiprakash Kulkarni and Another v. The Banking Ombudsman and Others, the Bombay High Court held that the petitioners were not liable for unauthorised electronic transfers caused by a third-party breach and directed Bank of Baroda to refund the disputed amount with interest.
Neutral citation: 2024:BHC-OS:8627-DB
Decision: 13 June 2024
Bench: Justices G. S. Kulkarni and Firdosh P. Pooniwalla
Refund ordered: Rs. 76,90,017 with interest at 6% per annum from 2 October 2022 until payment
Background of the cyber fraud
The petitioners, Jaiprakash Kulkarni and Pharma Search Ayurveda Private Limited, maintained a corporate current account with Bank of Baroda at its Worli branch. On 1 October 2022, unauthorised beneficiaries were added and electronic transfers amounting to Rs. 76,90,017 were made without the petitioners' authorisation. They asserted that they had not received the relevant one-time passwords or bank notifications.
A cybercrime complaint was registered and the matter was pursued before the Banking Ombudsman. The Ombudsman rejected the complaint, finding no deficiency in the bank's service. The petitioners challenged that decision before the High Court.
What the High Court found
The Division Bench considered three Cyber Cell reports. These indicated that the relevant communications concerning the beneficiary changes and transfers were not received on the registered mobile number or email address and did not establish collusion by the petitioners with the fraudsters.
The Court found that the Ombudsman had not adequately investigated whether the transactions were authorised. Merely relying on the apparent use of credentials or two-factor authentication was insufficient in the circumstances.
RBI rules on customer liability
The judgment applied the Reserve Bank of India's 6 July 2017 circular, Customer Protection - Limiting Liability of Customers in Unauthorised Electronic Banking Transactions, and the bank's customer-protection policy. The circular's framework distinguished between bank negligence, third-party breaches and customer negligence.
| Situation under the 2017 circular | Customer liability |
|---|---|
| Fraud, negligence or deficiency attributable to the bank | Zero, regardless of reporting time |
| Third-party breach reported within three working days of receipt of bank communication | Zero |
| Third-party breach reported within four to seven working days | Limited to the applicable prescribed cap or transaction value, whichever is lower |
| Third-party breach reported after seven working days | As determined by the bank's board-approved policy |
| Loss attributable to customer's sharing of credentials or similar negligence | Customer bears loss until reporting; subsequent loss is borne by the bank |
Under that circular, the bank bore the burden of proving customer liability. It also provided for a provisional credit within ten working days of notification, subject to its prescribed framework. These principles are not an unconditional guarantee of reimbursement for every cyber fraud.
Regulatory update: The 2017 circular is the instrument considered in this 2024 judgment. RBI subsequently consolidated banking instructions in 2025. For a new dispute, customers should check the current RBI directions and the applicable bank policy rather than assume an earlier circular remains independently operative.
Relevant statutory provisions
Section 43A of the Information Technology Act, 2000
This provision addresses compensation where a body corporate handling sensitive personal data or information is negligent in implementing and maintaining reasonable security practices and procedures, causing wrongful loss or gain. Its application depends on the statutory requirements and relevant facts; it was among the provisions cited in the underlying cybercrime complaint.
Section 66 of the Information Technology Act, 2000
Section 66 concerns specified computer-related acts committed dishonestly or fraudulently and prescribes criminal punishment. It should be read with the acts described in Section 43 of that Act.
Section 379 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860
The complaint concerning the 2022 incident also referred to Section 379 IPC, which prescribed punishment for theft. The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 came into force on 1 July 2024, with corresponding theft provisions in Section 303; the law applicable to earlier conduct must be considered with the relevant savings provisions.
Final order of the Bombay High Court
By its judgment dated 13 June 2024, the Court quashed the Banking Ombudsman's order dated 10 January 2023 and directed Bank of Baroda to refund Rs. 76,90,017 within six weeks, together with interest at 6% per annum from 2 October 2022 until payment. No costs were awarded.
What should customers do after an unauthorised bank transaction?
- Immediately notify the bank through its official fraud-reporting channel and retain the complaint reference.
- Ask the bank to block compromised access and preserve transaction, device, beneficiary and authentication logs.
- Report the incident through the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal or the 1930 cyber-fraud helpline.
- Preserve account statements, SMS and email alerts, screenshots and correspondence.
- If the bank does not resolve the complaint, examine the grievance procedure and the RBI Complaint Management System, subject to applicable eligibility and timelines.
Why the judgment matters
The decision reinforces the need to examine the actual evidence of authorisation, the delivery of bank alerts and the applicable customer-liability rules. A transaction's apparent completion through electronic credentials does not, by itself, dispose of a properly supported allegation of cyber fraud.
Case reference and official resources
Case: Jaiprakash Kulkarni and Another v. The Banking Ombudsman and Others, Writ Petition No. 1150 of 2023, 2024:BHC-OS:8627-DB, decided 13 June 2024. See the Bombay High Court official website for judgment search and court records; the reported judgment text is also available for reference.
Appearances: Siddhesh Bhole, Yakshay Chheda and Anushree Koparkar for the petitioners; Aditi Pathak, Parag Sharma, Vijay Salokhe, Kirti Ojha and Megha More for the RBI/Ombudsman; Anvita Ail and Naresh H. Manghnani for Bank of Baroda; Additional Government Pleader Mohit Jadhav for the State.
This article explains the reported judgment and the regulatory framework applied to its facts. It is general legal information, not a determination of liability in any individual banking dispute.
