LawDadi - Indian law and legal information
Home / Code of Civil Procedure / Order XIV Rule 4

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 | Order 14

Order XIV Rule 4 CPC - Examination of Witnesses and Documents Before Framing Issues

Order XIV Rule 4 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) empowers a civil court to seek the attendance of a person or production of a document when that step is necessary to frame the issues correctly. The rule also provides for a limited adjournment of the framing of issues.

Statutory provision: Order XIV Rule 4 CPC

4. Court may examine witnesses or documents before framing issues. - Where the Court is of opinion that the issues cannot be correctly framed without the examination of some person not before the Court or without the inspection of some document not produced in the suit, it may adjourn the framing of issues to a day not later than seven days and may (subject to any law for the time being in force) compel the attendance of any person or the production of any document by the person in whose possession or power it is by summons or other process.

Source: Government of India, India Code - Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (PDF). The seven-day wording was substituted by section 24 of the Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Act, 1999, effective 1 July 2002.

Meaning and purpose of Order XIV Rule 4

An issue is a disputed material proposition of fact or law requiring determination by the court. Under Order XIV Rule 1, issues arise when one party affirms a material proposition and the other denies it. Correctly framed issues help define what must be decided at trial.

Rule 4 deals with a situation where the pleadings and existing record do not give the court sufficient clarity to identify those disputed propositions. Rather than frame incomplete or inaccurate issues, the court may seek further assistance through examination of a person or inspection of a document.

When can the court exercise this power?

1. Examination of a person not before the court

If the court considers a person's examination necessary for accurate framing of issues, it may require that person to attend. The power is linked to the need to settle the issues, not to a general right to call every proposed trial witness at this stage.

2. Inspection of a document not produced in the suit

The court may direct production of a document that has not yet been produced, where inspection is necessary to identify the real dispute. The direction is subject to applicable legal restrictions, including rules governing production, privilege and admissibility.

3. Summons or other lawful process

The court may use summons or another process permitted by law to secure attendance or production from the person who possesses or controls the document. Related procedural provisions include Order XVI (summoning and attendance of witnesses) and Order XI (discovery and inspection, as applicable).

Seven-day limit on adjournment

Order XIV Rule 4 permits the court to adjourn the framing of issues to a day not later than seven days when the prescribed need for examination or inspection arises. This is a specific statutory limit for an adjournment under Rule 4; it should not be read as a general seven-day deadline for every step in every civil suit.

Practical illustration

Suppose a plaintiff claims ownership of land under a deed, while the defendant disputes the nature of the document relied upon. If the court cannot accurately frame the disputed issue without examining a relevant person or inspecting an unproduced document, it may invoke Rule 4 to obtain that material before settling the issues, subject to the conditions in the rule.

Relationship with other CPC rules

  • Order XIV Rule 1: explains when issues arise and how they are framed.
  • Order XIV Rule 3: identifies the allegations, pleadings, interrogatory answers and documents from which issues may be framed.
  • Order XIV Rule 5: addresses amendment, addition and striking out of issues.

Key legal points

The power under Rule 4 is discretionary and must serve the purpose of correctly framing issues. The court may seek necessary clarification, but the provision does not dispense with the normal rules on proof or determine the merits of the suit. Applicable High Court rules, state amendments and special procedures, including those governing commercial disputes, should also be checked in the relevant case.

Official legal reference

Read the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 on India Code (official PDF), particularly the First Schedule, Order XIV, Rules 1 to 5. The text and explanation above describe the general central provision.